Mediation vs. Litigation: The Advantages of Settling Out of Court

by Jeffrey J. Downey, Esq

Legal disputes are a part of life; when conflicts arise, your first instinct might be to head straight to court. After all, it is where justice is served, right? Before you dive into the complex world of litigation, there is an alternative worth considering: mediation. This article addresses  the advantages of choosing mediation over litigation, even when your case seems rock-solid.

Advantages That Mediation Brings To Your Case

When you are in a legal dispute and believe you have a strong case, the courtroom may seem like the natural destination for justice, but there is more to the story. Before you decide on litigation, consider the world of alternative dispute resolution, specifically mediation.

It is a powerful approach, with statistics revealing that nearly 80% to 85% of mediated cases result in settlements, showing just how effective it can be. Below are the advantages that a Virginia mediator brings to the table:

Cost-Effectiveness and Time Efficiency

Legal proceedings can be costly and time-consuming. Your finances can take a significant hit between court fees, expert expenses, and the lengthy litigation process. Conversely, mediation is usually much more cost-effective, involving fewer meetings and less time. This means you can resolve your dispute efficiently and save substantial money.

Mediation is often quicker than both litigation and arbitration. Mediation focuses on a collaborative approach where both parties work together to find a resolution. Sessions can last from a few hours to a few days, with most disputes settled in just one session. In contrast, litigation is typically the slowest method, involving multiple processes that can take months or even years.

Collecting Your Hard-Earned Money: A Challenging Reality

Winning a judgment in court is only the beginning. There is no guarantee that you will receive the money owed to you promptly, if at all. Enforcing a judgment can be challenging, often involving asset hiding, bankruptcy declarations, or an outright payment refusal. This can lead to further legal battles and increased expenses, especially where the Defendant seeks the protection of bankruptcy laws.

Conversely, mediation settlement agreements are implemented voluntarily in most cases. Parties willingly agree to the terms, conditions, and guarantees, which reduces the risk of non-compliance. You will not need to worry about chasing after your hard-earned money.

Reduced Stress and Emotional Toll

The adversarial nature of litigation can be stressful. Mediation, with its collaborative approach, reduces emotional stress for everyone involved. You can maintain a balanced and less stressful atmosphere, leading to more productive discussions. In mediation, parties can meet separately with the mediator when joint meetings become unproductive, preventing emotional escalation.

Preserving Relationships

Legal disputes can strain or even break relationships between the parties involved. Litigation may bring conflicts to a resolution, but it doesn’t necessarily end them. The impact on relationships is often negative due to public blame and shame. Mediation, however, encourages open communication and collaboration, making it possible to resolve disagreements while preserving relationships.

For example, divorce mediation is particularly beneficial for families, as it can decrease the negative effects of divorce on children and family members. Mediation allows divorcing couples to communicate openly and find solutions that benefit their family’s needs. Similarly, business partners facing disputes can use mediation to resolve financial issues and address underlying communication problems, ultimately preserving their personal and business relationships.

Confidentiality and Privacy

Court proceedings are public, meaning sensitive information can become public knowledge. This can harm reputations and lead to unwanted publicity. Mediation, in contrast, is private and confidential. The discussions and agreements remain private, protecting your reputation and privacy. This confidentiality is generally formalized, providing a safe space for honest communication.

Control Over the Resolution

In court, the outcome rests in the hands of a judge or jury. Both parties can negotiate and craft an agreement that suits their needs in mediation. This collaborative approach allows for creative solutions that may not be possible in a courtroom. It gives you control over the resolution, reducing the risk of an unfavorable judgment.

Higher Compliance Rates

Mediation often leads to higher compliance rates. Since both parties are actively crafting the resolution, they are more likely to adhere willingly to the agreed-upon terms. In contrast, when a judge imposes a decision, one party may feel resentful or dissatisfied, leading to non-compliance or further disputes.  This can lead to a costly and time consuming appeal.

While the allure of the courtroom may be strong, mediation offers numerous advantages that make it a compelling alternative. It can lead to more satisfying outcomes, save time and money, preserve relationships, and protect your privacy.


If you are looking for a Mediator, call the Law Office of Jeffrey J. Downey.   Mr. Downey has represented both Defendants and Plaintiffs in a wide variety of legal disputes including personal injury, medical malpractice, elder abuse and neglect and commercial matters.  He brings over 30 years of litigation experience and can also offer evaluative services to help bring the parties together.

For more information, call the Law Office of Jeffrey J. Downey.  We handle disputes in Virginia, Maryland and Washington D.C.

Contact Information:

The Law Office of Jeffrey J. Downey

8300 Greensboro Drive, Suite 500

McLean, Virginia 22102

Phone: 703-564-7318

Fax: 703-556-7700